Published on InTouch (

The Lost Option: Australia and the British Monarchy



Associate Professor Jim Davidson
Honorary (Principal Fellow)
School of Historical and Philosophical Studies

Principal Research Fellow (Honorary) at the Australian Centre in the School of Historical and Philosophical Studies, Associate Professor Jim Davidson, is primarily a biographer.  His recent biography of Sir Keith Hancock, A Three-Cornered Life, was described by Geoffrey Blainey as “one of the very best Australian biographies about a mind at work”.  Between them his two biographies have won six prizes, including the Prime Minister’s History Prize for 2011.

Underlying this lecture is the question posed by Brazil, which in the nineteenth century slid out of the Portuguese orbit with an Emperor of its own.  Why was there no similar royal devolution in the British Empire?  Instead, there have been deliberate attempts to strengthen the monarchy in Australia, not least by Labor governments.  The present-day situation is considered, with its revival of royal popularity.

Basically, the republicans (promoting an Australian head of state) and the monarchists (who cherish our existing forms of government) are talking past each other. An Australian constitutional monarchy would reconcile the two positions - but it has become a lost option.

Meanwhile the British royal family goes through its paces, more as visiting celebrities than anything else.


Wednesday, 4 April 2012 | 6.30pm to 7.30pm 

Theatre D
Ground Floor, Old Arts Building
The University of Melbourne

Location map

Contact June McBeth in the School of Historical & Philosophical Studies at or 8344 5142.

Connect with us Follow the Melbourne Uni Alumni Facebook page  Follow the University of Melbourne Alumni LinkedIn group  View the University of Melbounre Alumni photostream  Follow us on Twitter
Date created: 27 July 2010
Last modified: 22 September 2011
Authoriser: Director of Alumni Relations
Maintainer: Alumni Relations
The University of Melbourne ABN: 84 002 705 224
CRICOS Provider Number 00116K (visa information)
Accessibility | Disclaimer & copyrightPrivacy |  Website terms of use